What FMCSA decided

FMCSA's September 29 public-inspection notice denies the Federation of Professional Truckers' application to let participating professional drivers record their records of duty status manually instead of using an electronic logging device.

The agency said the application did not establish an equivalent or greater level of safety. FMCSA also said Congress directed the agency to require ELDs for interstate commercial vehicles operated by drivers who must keep records of duty status, preventing the blanket exemption the applicant requested.

What does not change

The denial is a final disposition of this exemption request; it is not a new ELD rule and it does not create a new compliance deadline. Drivers currently required to use an ELD remain required to do so.

Existing limited exceptions remain governed by current law. The notice specifically points to the rule allowing manual records when a driver needs a record of duty status on no more than eight days within a 30-day period. Other existing exceptions depend on their own facts and were not expanded by this decision.

Driver meaning

Drivers and carriers should not switch to paper logs based on the exemption campaign or earlier reports that FMCSA was considering the request. A driver may use paper only when an existing exception, malfunction procedure or other valid rule specifically allows it.

The docket received 901 comments, including 890 unique comments. FMCSA summarized both supporting and opposing views, but the final decision turned on statutory authority and the applicant's failure to meet the required safety-equivalence standard.

Primary sources and supporting records

No corrections have been recorded for this article. Read our editorial and corrections policy.